In the days since Nancy Guthrie disappeared, her home has become a shrine to everything that suddenly stopped: half-finished routines, familiar photos, the quiet comfort of knowing she was just a phone call away. Now, every unanswered ring feels like a taunt. Her family lives in a loop of what-ifs, replaying the last conversations, wondering if there was some hidden plea for help they somehow missed.

For Savannah Guthrie, whose job is to give shape to other people’s tragedies, the roles have reversed with brutal force. She is now the one waiting on the porch, scanning every update, every rumor, every knock at the door. The police investigation moves behind closed doors, but the family’s grief is painfully public. Between hope and heartbreak, they cling to one stubborn belief: until Nancy is found, her story is not over.